A colorful maze of books

The Hidden Reason Book Marketing Fails for Smart Nonfiction Authors

January 16, 20266 min read

This concept caught my attention when I read it in a recent newsletter fromJames Clear. Two short lines that seemed simple on the surface and quietly demanding underneath.

“To learn, wander. To achieve, focus.”

As soon as I read it, I thought about book marketing and why so many capable nonfiction authors stall after publication. Not because they lack effort or intelligence, but because they confuse exploration with execution.

Learning rewards wandering. Book marketing punishes it.

Most authors never separate the two.

Where Authors Go Wrong Early

Most nonfiction authors approach book marketing backward.

They chase tactics before clarity. They try to grow visibility before they know what they want that visibility to produce. They post everywhere, pitch everyone, and say yes to opportunities that feel productive but lead nowhere.

The result is motion without momentum.

The quote sounds obvious. It’s not. It exposes a tension most authors refuse to confront.

Learning expands options. Marketing requires constraint.

When authors blur that line, books drift.

Example:
My first books sold over 500,000 copies to a single organization. That didn’t happen because of a launch, rankings, or online buzz. It happened because the book solved a specific problem for a specific buyer at scale.

There was no wandering once that became clear.

Action item:
Write down every marketing activity you are doing right now. Circle the ones which directly support one clear outcome. Pause the rest for 90 days.

The Amateur Tries Everything

The Master Chooses Carefully

There is a harsh truth about book marketing.

Most authors don’t fail because they lack information. They fail because they refuse to choose.

They jump from strategy to strategy while telling themselves they are “still learning.” What they are really doing is protecting themselves from committing to a direction that might require repetition.

The amateur doesn’t know what to do, so everything feels possible.

The master knows what not to do, so progress accelerates.

In book marketing, mastery looks dull from the outside. It looks repetitive. It looks narrow. It looks like saying no to good ideas in service of a better one.

Example:

One of my coaching started off marketing her book to individual readers. Sales trickled in. Once she focused on associations who served her niche and positioned the book as a resource for members, bulk orders followed. The book didn’t change, her focus did.

Action item:
Finish this sentence:
“This book exists to __________________.”
If you can’t answer it in one line, your marketing will stay scattered.

Wandering Has a Job

Revenue isn’t it!

Wandering isn’t the enemy. Staying there is.

Early exploration matters. You need time to test language, notice what questions people ask, and discover which parts of your message create engagement.

That phase belongs to learning, not selling.

Many authors rush to monetize before they understand what their book actually does for readers.

They pitch talks they can‘t’ yet articulate clearly.
They market ideas they have not yet refined through conversation.
They abandon messages before letting them mature.

Wandering helps you discover what your book is really about beyond the table of contents.

The mistake is treating wandering as a permanent strategy.

Example:
One of my coaching clients noticed a clear pattern. Every time she mentioned the same chapter from her book, decision-makers asked how they could apply it with their teams. That insight didn’t come from chasing new ideas. It came from repeating the same one. Once she focused on that application, bulk sales followed.

Action item:
Look back at the last five conversations where someone engaged deeply with your book. What theme keeps showing up? That’s where focus belongs.

You Won’t Have Your Best Idea First

This is where patience separates professionals from dabblers.

It’s almost impossible to have your best idea the first time you think about something. That applies to your positioning, your promise, and your market role.

Your first version is supposed to be rough.
Your second version is supposed to be clearer.
Your tenth version is where authority begins to show.

Time unlocks insights. Volume alone doesn’t do it.

The authors who sell books in bulk and attract organizations don’t chase novelty. They revisit the same problem long enough for sharper insights to emerge.

They allow repetition to do its work.

Example:
I’ve seen authors refine a single framework over years of doing workshops. By the time organizations bought the book in bulk, the ideas had already been tested, proven, and trusted.

Action item:
Choose one idea from your book to revisit publicly for the next six months. Refine it rather than replacing it.

Focus Is What Turns a Book Into an Asset

Focus begins with deciding what your book is for.

Not who it’s for. Rather, What it’s for.

Is it meant to…

Open doors to organizations?
Anchor speaking engagements?
Support consulting or training?
Establish authority in a narrow niche?

A book that tries to do all of this at once does none of it well.

Focus requires subtraction. It requires choosing which outcome matters now and which can wait.

This is where most authors hesitate.

Example:
When I help authors shift from general readers to buyers who purchase in volume, visibility becomes more focused, and revenue increases.

Action item:
Pick one buyer type your book should serve this year. Build everything around that decision.

Respect Comes From Alignment, Not Volume

Ancient wisdom dismantles modern marketing culture.

Lao Tzu observed that when someone stops competing, comparison loses power.

Paraphrased from the Tao Te Ching, the teaching suggests that respect emerges from self-alignment rather than performance.

This applies directly to book marketing.

Authors who chase trends sound interchangeable.

Authors who speak from alignment sound grounded.

When you stop comparing your book launch to someone else’s success, your voice steadies. Your message sharpens. Your confidence grows because it’s anchored in experience rather than noise.

Example:
On many occasions, I turned down flashy opportunities that didn’t match my market. Over time, buyers began seeking me out as a specialist rather than a generalist.

Action item:
List three marketing opportunities you should decline this quarter. Alignment beats exposure.

Authority Comes From Staying Put

Here is the contrarian truth.

Authority doesn’t come from reach. It comes from consistency.

The authors who appear everywhere are often forgettable.

The authors who appear focused are remembered.

They show up with the same problem, the same audience, and the same lens long enough for trust to form.

Their book sells because it stands for a specific purpose.

Their opportunities compound because people know exactly when to think of them.

What Is This Teaching You?

It reveals a different way of working.

Exploration opens the door. Focus moves things forward. Messages deepen when they’re revisited, and insight shows up when time is allowed to do its job.

With clarity in place, your book starts to carry its own weight. Opportunities follow, and marketing turns from a grind into a return on your focus.

Susan Friedmann, CSP, is a trailblazer in the world of nonfiction book and author marketing coaching and training. With over 30 years of experience, she’s on a mission to help you stand out from the crowd. Say goodbye to blending in — Susan injects life into your book marketing game.

Susan Friedmann

Susan Friedmann, CSP, is a trailblazer in the world of nonfiction book and author marketing coaching and training. With over 30 years of experience, she’s on a mission to help you stand out from the crowd. Say goodbye to blending in — Susan injects life into your book marketing game.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Back to Blog